Longer Car Loans, Same Old Chapter 13 Plan Term: The New Vehicle Treatment Problem
Car loans are getting longer. Chapter 13 plans are not.
That mismatch is creating a growing problem for vehicle lenders in consumer bankruptcy cases. A debtor may enter Chapter 13 with a 72- or 84-month vehicle loan, but the plan itself cannot exceed 60 months. When the note outlasts the plan, the treatment of the vehicle claim becomes more complicated than the traditional surrender, cramdown, or 910-claim analysis.
If the debtor wants to pay the vehicle claim in full through the plan, the Bankruptcy Code provides one path. If the debtor wants to maintain ongoing contractual payments on a loan that extends beyond the plan term, the Code provides another. But what the debtor is not permitted to do is create a hybrid treatment: maintain the long-term contract payment structure while also reducing the contractual interest rate to a Till ratei.
Up until recently, the most common vehicle loan treatments under Chapter 13 plans were:
Surrender: Lender gets the vehicle, liquidates it, and may file a deficiency claim treated as a general unsecured claim.
910 Treatment: If the vehicle was purchased within 910 days prior to bankruptcy filing, the debtor generallyii cannot cram down the principal balance but may pay in full through the life of the plan at a Till rate of interest.
Cramdown: If available, the secured claim is based on collateral value rather than the full amount owed, typically with Till interest.
Under these three options, all the funds tendered toward the claim are paid by the Chapter 13 Trustee throughout the case with the goal being met by the time discharge is issued.
What happens when the car note lasts longer than the bankruptcy plan?
Assume a debtor buys a vehicle six months before bankruptcy on an 84-month note at 19% interest. The Chapter 13 plan can last only 60 months. If the debtor tries to keep making the contract payment directly, the loan will still exist after the bankruptcy ends. The debtor may want the best of both worlds: keep the long-term payment structure but reduce the interest rate to a Till rate. That is where the problem begins.
The Bankruptcy Code is clear on this issue. The “new” concept here is that vehicle loans under these extended terms are no longer short-term debts. Simply put, short-term debt is any secured claim under which the final payment has come due prior to or during the bankruptcy case. Long-term debt is therefore the situation in which the contractual term of the note exceeds the bankruptcy timeline of 60 months. What remains of a 72- or 84-month vehicle loan at the time of the bankruptcy filing could very easily exceed the term of the bankruptcy.
This is not a new concept in bankruptcy generally… it just isn’t normally how we think about vehicle claims. Ordinarily, we view long-term debt as it relates to real estate claims. These extended terms aren’t abnormal when the average mortgage loan is 25 to 30 years long. But then, the collateral of land isn’t nearly as perishable as a vehicle driving down the road.
In usual fashion, the Bankruptcy Code seems to clearly favor balancing the interests of all parties involved. Effectively, the Code by containing the following provisions working in tandem, 11 USC 1322(b)(2)iii, (b)(5)iv and 11 USC 1325(a)(5)(B)(i)v allows a debtor to maintain their ongoing contractual payments but does not allow a debtor to also cram down on the contractual interest. Each of these sections directs a debtor on a path of proper claim treatment.
A. Section 1322(b)(2): modification permitted
Debtors may generally modify the rights of secured creditors, except for claims secured only by the debtor’s principal residence.
B. Section 1322(b)(5): cure and maintain for long-term debt
If the final payment comes due after the plan ends, the debtor may cure defaults and maintain ongoing payments while the case is pending.
C. Section 1325(a)(5)(B): cramdown treatment
If the debtor modifies the secured claim and pays it through the plan, the creditor retains its lien until the earlier of payment of the underlying debt or discharge.
These provisions create options, not a menu for mixing and matching. A debtor may modify the claim and pay it through the plan, or the debtor may maintain the long-term contract obligation under § 1322(b)(5). But a debtor should not be permitted to maintain the extended repayment schedule while also replacing the contractual interest rate with a reduced cramdown rate.
If a discharge is not going to apply to the contract, because the term and repayment will extend beyond the discharge, then reducing the interest rate during the plan will only result in unpaid interest due after plan completion. A debtor may not assert a treatment in which the debtor makes ongoing contractual payments throughout the entire term of the bankruptcy while cramming down the interest from the contractual higher rate to that of a fair Till rate.
The majority of courts have held that the choice is clearly an either/or situation and the desired effect of cramdown cannot be coupled with the maintain and cure methodology. As the court clearly states in In re Brown, 399 B.R. 30, 33 (Bankr. C.D. Ill. 2007) “The Bankruptcy Code does not authorize a Chapter 13 debtor to cure a default and simultaneously modify the secured claim. In re Hussain, 250 B.R. 502 (Bankr.D.N.J.2000). The DEBTOR must choose one or the other. The DEBTOR could have proposed a plan which provided for the payment of all future installment payments, the cure of all delinquent payments, and the payment of applicable interest.”
What’s the harm, though?
Harm 1: The interest shortfall survives the case
If the debtor maintains the contract as a long-term debt, the discharge does not rewrite the surviving contractual obligation. If the plan pays only a reduced Till rate of interest during the case, the unpaid difference between the contract rate and the reduced rate may remain due after the plan ends.
Harm 2: Accelerated repayment may distort the plan
In some cases, the courts may not even allow the debtor to bring the contract fully into the plan to protect the interests of other creditors. Courts have held that plans proposed with this attempted cramdown are not proposed in good faith. Debtors attempting to bring a long-term debt into the short term of the bankruptcy are doing so at the expense of the unsecured creditors.
Attempting to pay off a large quantity of secured debt faster than under the contractual terms would decrease the available surplus budgetary funds that could be directed toward unsecured claims. The unsecured creditor pool should not be the party responsible for forfeiting funds for the benefit of the debtor and their secured lender. As the court states in In re Page, 658 B.R. 178, 192 (Bankr. E.D. Wash. 2024), “The proposed plan would provide the debtors with an inappropriate “head start” at the expense of their unsecured creditors rather than offering a chance at bankruptcy's “fresh start.”” This “head start” is never the goal of the court, which focuses on balancing the interests of all parties.
Additionally, forcing a debtor to reduce the term of their vehicle contract to fit within the term of a bankruptcy could result in an unaffordable plan payment and unnecessary additional strain on the debtor’s already tight budget. This could make the plan payment impossible for the debtor and the success of the bankruptcy unlikely.
And so it goes…
Until there is a permanent change to the Bankruptcy Codevi that lengthens the term of a bankruptcy, an ideal solution that truly improves a debtor’s financial position may not be available to every debtor. Longer vehicle loans have changed the economics of consumer lending, but they have not changed the structure of Chapter 13.
When a vehicle obligation extends beyond the life of the bankruptcy case, it may be treated as the long-term debt it has become. Debtors remain free to modify the claim or maintain the contract, but they cannot rewrite the agreement to capture the advantages of both approaches. The Bankruptcy Code requires a choice, and the growing length of vehicle loans provides no basis to avoid making one. It seems this trend of longer-term vehicle loans is truly a hazard blocking the road to bankruptcy success. As a result, lenders and practitioners may see a growing shift from retention-based plan treatments toward vehicle surrender as debtors struggle to make the numbers work.
* Please note this article originally appeared in the Fall 2026 issue of ALFN ANGLE.
Footnotes
i For purposes of this article, “Till rate” refers generally to the formula approach derived from Till v. SCS Credit Corp., 541 U.S. 465 (2004), typically beginning with the prime rate and adjusting upward based on case-specific risk.
ii The limitation of treatments regarding a vehicle purchased within 910 days does not apply to vehicles purchased for non-personal usage or non-purchase money security interest transactions.
iii (b) Subject to subsections (a) and (c) of this section, the plan may:
(2) modify the rights of holders of secured claims, other than a claim secured only by a security interest in real property that is the debtor's principal residence, or of holders of unsecured claims, or leave unaffected the rights of holders of any class of claims.
iv (b) Subject to subsections (a) and (c) of this section, the plan may:
(5) notwithstanding paragraph (2) of this subsection, provide for the curing of any default within a reasonable time and maintenance of payments while the case is pending on any unsecured claim or secured claim on which the last payment is due after the date on which the final payment under the plan is due;
v (a) Except as provided in subsection (b), the court shall confirm a plan if:
(5) with respect to each allowed secured claim provided for by the plan:
(B) (i) the plan provides that:
(I) the holder of such claim retain the lien securing such claim until the earlier of:
(aa) the payment of the underlying debt determined under nonbankruptcy law; or
(bb) discharge under section 1328; and
vi During the COVID relief CARES Act, debtors could modify their confirmed Chapter 13 plans to extend to 84 months total due to COVID-related loss of income and loss of employment. Those rights under the Act expired and are no longer available to debtors.
This publication is for informational purposes only and does not constitute an opinion of MDK.
Do not rely on this publication without seeking legal counsel.
It all starts with a conversation
Let’s talk about how MDK can help you streamline operations, protect your interests, and drive results. Contact Brittany Anderson today to schedule your introduction call.
Schedule a Call





